Tampa Bay Buccaneers Draft Needs 2010
By Position - With UPDATES (2/10/2010)
QUARTERBACK
Just recognize that the Bucs have a Franchise QB in Josh Freeman now, and they currently have a second-year QB in Josh Johnson as a back-up. Filling the third spot on the roster for QB with yet another newbie borders on insane and inept. The Bucs should not and ought not waste any draft picks this year on a rookie QB. Done.
I didn't agree with picking Freeman last year, I admit that. I'm still not sure how he'll work out. But this is his job now, his offense to lead, so let him have at it.
ODDS: VERY LOW PROJECTED ROUND: None
RUNNING BACK/FULLBACK
The Running Back/Fullback situation for the Bucs is still tied to Cadillac Williams, who rebounded from his knee injuries with a solid but unspectacular season last year. The good news is that towards the end in December, the coaches started giving Williams more touches and he responded with impressive games.
As for the backups, Ward proved to be bit of a bust mostly due to the coaches trying too much to rotate the duties between him and Caddy. Graham remains a workhorse powerback type who was forced by injuries to fill the FB duties for a few months. Add kick returner Clifton James into the mix and the Bucs aren't really in the need for a rookie RB. The Bucs *could* waste a low-round pick as they've done the past few years on an RB, but I doubt it. Odds are better that a FB could be under consideration, based on the injury problems as mentioned for last year.
ODDS: VERY LOW PROJECTED ROUND: FB only - Seventh
WIDE RECEIVER

The weakest part of the Bucs offense going into the 2010 off-season is clearly the WR spot. The team only had Bryant as a definite threat, with everyone else on the WR depth chart - especially Clayton and Stovall - unable to fill the needed No. 2 slot. Dexter Jackson from two years ago proved one thing - he was clearly overdrafted (I had posted back then why he was taken when other WRs with better scouting reports were passed up). Only rookie Sammie Stroughter stepped up as a nice Third-Down drive-saving possession receiver especially during the second half of the season, turning into Freeman's second-favorite target (after TE Winslow).
I screamed last year that the Bucs needed a WR more than QB, and this year I'm still screaming it. Problem is, this year it doesn't make sense for the Bucs to waste (and it would be) such a high spot on the draft (third overall!) on a flaky ego-driven WR you tend to get in the high rounds. Given more serious needs at key positions Defensive Tackle, Safety and Offensive Tackle, a receiver can wait until the Second Round.
Given the questionable Free Agency market for 2010, is there a veteran WR available that would be a value addition for a balanced threat opposite Bryant? And will the Bucs be able to keep Bryant, who's gotta be tempted to test this market?

ODDS: HIGH PROJECTED ROUND: Second to Third
TIGHT END
Kellen Winslow proved to be the best acquisition the team got last year. Trading away TE Alex Smith did get rid of a talented but injury-prone up-and-comer, so a question of youth at the TE position is there. Everyone else on the roster here are aging veterans (Stevens, Gilmore) or a Practice Squader.
The Bucs don't need a TE as a starter, merely for two-TE formations and for back-up / development. I can see a mid-draft selection, probably Fourth or Fifth, depending on how the earlier rounds went and if the Bucs secure any Compensatory picks.
ODDS: LOW PROJECTED ROUND: Fourth to Sixth
OFFENSIVE TACKLE
The offensive line was solid but unspectacular this past season, mostly due to loss of Aaron Sears to off-field issues and problematic play from our starting OTs. Penn I think is a Free Agent (again) and was disgruntled about his place here in Tampa last I knew. Trueblood is a problem player: penalties all over the place, including some incredibly stupid personal foul habits that tends to kill drives.
Personally, I feel the Bucs are in a great position to draft Best Available OT in the Draft. Drafts are the only way to get a franchise OT - teams NEVER let good OTs flee via free agency - and the Bucs are going to need one if Freeman is going to get better as the team franchise QB. Problem here is, the Bucs have serious needs at DT, and there's a chance a game-breaking DT could be had (not Suh, who's clearly a lock for either First pick or Second overall, but McCoy, who's almost as good) expect the Bucs to go that route. If I were in charge of the draft war room (you hear that, Glazers? HIRE ME!), I'd have an OT as a First / Second Round need.
ODDS: HIGH PROJECTED ROUND: First to Second
OFFENSIVE GUARD
The Bucs had a few problems with the running game, and a lot of it had to do with OG Sears being out for off-field problems. Word is, he'll be coming back, and with Davin Joseph cementing the other OG spot, there's not too huge a need here past depth and development.
ODDS: LOW PROJECTED ROUND: Fifth to Seventh
CENTER
The FA acquisition of Faine proved a smart move. I didn't see much wrong with his play. And one hopes he'll stay with the Bucs a good long while. The only question here is depth need (or will the Bucs keep training a back-up OG for duties here?).
If anyone read last year's preview, this is essentially what I wrote then. It still applies. The need is a bit greater for back-up development, of course, and one hopes the team figures out that developing an actual CENTER and not retraining a GUARD tends to be a better move.
ODDS: LOW PROJECTED ROUND: Sixth to Seventh
DEFENSIVE TACKLE

The Bucs did draft a DT in last year's Third Round (Miller) but I honestly can't recall him being on the field much. He is credited with 2 sacks, so I guess he was out there. But you see, this kind of highlights the problem the Bucs have with their Defensive Line: there's almost no evidence the D-Line did anything at all last season. And for a team that prides itself on Defense, whenever the D-Line is this bad, the team suffers.
The Bucs have an opportunity this year to secure a franchise lineman, being at the Third Overall draft pick. The BEST AVAILABLE PLAYER is a DT (SUH!!!!) and the next guy on the DT draft lists (MCCOY!!!) is as near a sure-fire selection as the top guy. This all depends a lot on the two teams picking ahead of the Bucs: The Rams have top overall and a DT like Suh would upgrade their defense, but they could also look at other needs (it's possible... slim but possible); the Lions are troubled all over the place as always, but a DT like Suh would be a no-brainer for them if the Rams pass, so it's a question on if the Lions will take McCoy or else think about boosting another need (like say OT... or Safety... or CB... or RB... or TE... or).
Odds are, unless the Bucs trade up (which could prove too costly), they won't see Suh at all. Odds are better that McCoy will slip to them. If neither are there, the Bucs can wait until Round Two to get a solid DT who can fit the team's One-Gap attack. But this is the deal: The Bucs Need Defensive Tackle. It's a No-Brainer Need.

ODDS: VERY HIGH PROJECTED ROUND: First to Second
DEFENSIVE END
The DE talent for the Bucs is as problematic as the Tackle slots. Despite some of the scouting reports, however, it's NOT as bad as other needs...
The Bucs do have solid guys on the ends (White, Wilkerson) and a decent rookie prospect (Moore) who showed flashes of talent last year. From my POV, the ends merely suffered from the lack of a penetrating DT presence that could have pulled away a lot of the blocking they ran into last year. A better DT means more one-on-one blocks. That means better chances of collapsing a QB's pocket.
The Bucs could use a middle-round draft pick (Third or so) for a developmental pass-rusher type who can be rotated in on obvious pass-play schemes. However, I don't see them using a First Rounder or either Second Rounders on a DE, as needs are higher elsewhere.
ODDS: MEDIUM PROJECTED ROUND: Third to Fifth
LINEBACKER
I admit to being pleasantly surprised by how the Linebacker corps survived the Purge of Brooks and Cato June last season. Quincy Black showed some skills, and Geno Hayes literally exploded out of nowhere as a questionable Sixth Rounder into a solid Cover-2 attacker. Ruud wasn't a breakout player as I'd have hoped, but he anchored the middle of the defense well, and if the rest of the defense improves, it usually helps the LBs.
The question now is one of depth. Depending on who's getting the development off the bench, there may be a need to fill a spot or two as needed. But considering the higher needs for DT, OT, WR and Safety, I doubt the Bucs will waste an early slot on an LB.
ODDS: LOW PROJECTED ROUND: Sixth to Seventh
CORNERBACK
The buzz is that the starting corners - Barber and Talib - are still good. Well, other than the fact that Barber slowed a bit towards the end of the season, and that Talib's got some off-field issues that can prove distracting and all...
The Bucs need to think long-term as well as short. Barber is clearly at the end of his career. The talent pool for CB isn't as good for the Bucs as I'd hope. The problem is that the backfield has problems at the Safety spot (Sabby?) that make it a slightly bigger need (Dammit, Sabby, it's called TACKLING!) than Corner.
There are too many other needs elsewhere for this to be a priority pick, but a serious look by the Third Round selection is a must.
ODDS: MEDIUM PROJECTED ROUND: Third to Fourth
SAFETY

For the first four games last year, the Bucs were without S Tanard Jackson, out on suspension. It showed: the Bucs defense was atrocious. Once he got back, however... the Bucs defense was still bad, but it proved to be new DC Gates' idiot idea of switching away from the Tampa-2 cover scheme to a more flexible defense that the players couldn't fit. Once Gates was shown the door and the Tampa-2 re-installed, the team improved...
As for the Safety spots, well Jackson is pretty much set: as for the other guy, Sabby Piscatelli, well the fans weren't entirely thrilled with his play. Missed assignments, missed tackles, letting WRs blow past him half the time... yeah, it proved disappointing. The depth of this position isn't so hot either: past Corey Lynch, I can't say who on the roster could step up as a starter.
This is why a good number of scouts are figuring the Bucs will take touted rookie S Eric Berry at the Third overall: the scouts already figure both DTs Suh and McCoy gone, and so they project the Bucs looking to the other glaring defensive hole at S. Some scouts are arguing a DE could go instead, but Safety is a seriously higher need.
If Suh (obviously) and McCoy ARE both gone by the Bucs' first pick, the odds are VERY good they could go with Berry. But I personally think the Bucs could wait until Round Two while grabbing best available OT in the First. Eh, that's me.

ODDS: HIGH PROJECTED ROUND: First to Third
KICKER /PUNTER
You do not draft for a Kicker or Punter in this day and age. UFAs are cheap and easy to get, and very few teams waste a high pick here, not since the heady days of Gramatica and whassisname for the Raidahs.
This entry will never change. Even if the Bucs DO get desperate for a Kicker...
ODDS: Nil PROJECTED ROUND: None

--

Back to Draft Page | Back to Bucs Page | Back to Witty Librarian Page | email me if I forgot that the Bucs needed to draft a new second baseman...wait...

--